Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Q&A 10, First Answer

The basic form of my question is: Are humans born with radical freedom, or do they develop this ability with age?

Early Sartre would probably suggest the former.  Later Sartre, however, might agree more with the latter.  I think he would likely say that humans should work towards achieving radical freedom, and that this effort will likely be a lifelong project.  Initially, humans are entirely dependent upon others to make their choices for them; later on, they become gradually more autonomous, until they are relatively free of others' influences.

My own viewpoint on this issue is virtually inapplicable, as I do not think that humans ever have radical freedom, both because I think that the universe is in fact predetermined and because I do not think that (even given the existence of free will) humans could ever be sufficiently free of outside influence as to be radically free.

No comments:

Post a Comment